Call Us! 0414 718 338

Situationships: All the Feelings, None of the Commitment?

A situationship is a romantic or sexual connection that lacks formal labels, clear commitment or an agreed understanding of the future.  It can feel like a relationship, look like a relationship and involve genuine emotional intimacy, yet leave one or both people wondering, “What exactly are we?”

In a world where relationships can begin through dating apps, social media and casual encounters, situationships have become an increasingly familiar part of modern dating.  But while the arrangement might begin casually, feelings don’t always remain that way.

The attraction can be real, but so can the uncertainty.

When connection and commitment don’t match

Situationships can involve regular messages, affection, sex, emotional support and spending considerable time together.  You might share personal experiences, discuss your day, make plans or turn to each other when life becomes difficult.  These interactions can create a strong sense of closeness.

However, closeness doesn’t automatically mean commitment, exclusivity or a shared vision for the future.

One person might view the connection as a relationship that is naturally developing, while the other enjoys the companionship and intimacy without wanting anything more.  Neither person is necessarily doing anything wrong, provided expectations are honest and boundaries are respected.  The difficulty arises when those expectations differ, remain unspoken or are deliberately avoided.

When actions feel like commitment but words remain unclear, it’s easy to fill the gaps with hope.

We might interpret frequent messages as evidence of growing feelings, affection as proof of exclusivity, or future plans as a sign that the relationship is heading somewhere.  These interpretations may be accurate, but they may also reflect what we want the connection to become rather than what has actually been agreed upon.

Why do we stay when we want more?

Sometimes, the uncertainty itself becomes part of the attachment.  The enjoyable moments create hope, while the absence of commitment creates doubt.  When affection and distance alternate, we may find ourselves paying even closer attention to messages, changes in behaviour and signs that the other person is becoming more invested.

We can become focused on understanding the other person’s intentions rather than checking in with our own needs.

We might tell ourselves to be patient, avoid appearing needy, give the connection more time or simply appreciate what we have. We may even convince ourselves that asking for clarity will ruin something that feels special.

But there is an important distinction between allowing a relationship to develop naturally and remaining in an arrangement that consistently leaves us feeling unsettled.

Are we enjoying the relationship we have, or holding on to the relationship we hope it will become?

Research by Joel and colleagues (2017) explored how people evaluate romantic relationships and make decisions about staying or leaving. Their work highlights the complexity of relationship decisions, particularly when emotional investment and uncertainty are involved. LeFebvre (2017) also examined how people navigate relationship endings and ambiguity in the digital age, reflecting the challenges of modern connections that do not always follow traditional patterns.

Is asking for clarity being needy?

Wanting to understand where you stand with someone is not automatically a sign of insecurity or neediness.  It can be a healthy expression of self-awareness, emotional honesty and respect for your own needs.

A conversation about expectations doesn’t require an immediate declaration of lifelong commitment.  It can simply mean asking whether you are both looking for the same thing, whether the connection is exclusive, or whether either of you sees the possibility of a committed relationship.

The other person is entitled to want something different. They may genuinely enjoy your company without wanting a relationship, and that preference deserves to be respected. Equally, you are entitled to decide that an undefined connection no longer meets your needs.

The goal isn’t to persuade someone to choose you.  It’s to establish whether you are both choosing the same kind of relationship.

Clarity isn’t pressure, and wanting commitment isn’t neediness.

Sometimes, the most difficult part of the conversation isn’t hearing that the other person wants something different.  It’s accepting that their answer may not be the one we have been hoping for.

When a situationship works — and when it doesn’t

Not every situationship is unhealthy.  Some people genuinely prefer a connection without formal labels or long-term expectations.  They may enjoy companionship, intimacy and independence without wanting a traditional relationship.

When both people communicate honestly, understand the arrangement and feel comfortable with it, the connection may work well.

Problems are more likely to arise when one person is content with the uncertainty while the other is quietly waiting for things to change.  Resentment can build when needs go unspoken, boundaries become blurred or one person repeatedly accepts less than they want because they fear losing the connection altogether.

It can help to ask yourself:

Am I comfortable with this arrangement as it is today?

  • Can I express my needs without fearing that the connection will disappear?
  • Are we both honest about what we want?
  • Am I making decisions based on what this person has communicated, or on what I hope their behaviour means?
  • If nothing changed over the next six months, would I still want to be here?

These questions aren’t about judging the other person.  They are about understanding your own emotional experience and making choices that align with your values.

Choosing yourself doesn’t mean the connection wasn’t real

It is possible to care deeply about someone and still recognise that the relationship isn’t right for you.  The feelings can be genuine, the memories meaningful and the connection important, even if you want different things.

Walking away doesn’t mean you imagined the connection or that it meant nothing.  It may simply mean you have recognised a difference between what you share and what you need.

Likewise, staying doesn’t have to mean abandoning your needs, provided you are making an informed choice rather than waiting indefinitely for someone else to decide your future.

Healthy relationships don’t require every answer from the beginning, but they do benefit from honest communication, mutual respect and the willingness to discuss difficult questions.

Ultimately, a label cannot guarantee emotional security, just as the absence of a label doesn’t automatically mean a connection lacks value.  What matters is whether both people understand the arrangement, feel respected and can make decisions without being kept in a state of uncertainty.

You don’t have to convince someone to want the same things you want.  You do, however, owe yourself the honesty to recognise when you don’t want the same things.

A question worth sitting with

If nothing changed and this connection stayed exactly as it is today, would you still choose it — or are you waiting to be chosen?

References